"I will remember that I remain a member of society, with special obligations to all my
fellow human beings, those sound of mind and body as well as the infirm."
From the modern Hippocratic Oath
For Wichita, Kansas, it all began back in 1998 with Paul Uhlig, M.D.
Who is Paul Uhlig?
He’s a fourth generation Kansas physician, a cardiothoracic surgeon, and the founding
president of the Central Plains Regional Health Care Foundation.
He’s also a man with insight and determination, who set the wheels in motion to provide
access to health care for the uninsured of Wichita.
And that’s no small feat.
The community had been trying here and there, in bits and pieces, to help the uninsured
get the care they needed. But their efforts were haphazard and unorganized. As a
consequence, indigent care services already provided by the area’s dedicated health care
professionals were uncoordinated and not seen as making a significant impact.
So, through the Central Plains Regional Health Care Foundation, a non-profit
organization that he established, Dr. Uhlig led discussions with various health care and
government leaders, exploring what existed in the community — particularly the
organizations that were already engaged in indigent health care: the SCAMU clinics.
(SCAMU, for the uninitiated, is short for the Sedgwick County Association for the
Medically Uninsured.)
At that time, each of these clinics had a private list of physicians whom they could
contact when one of their indigent patients needed specialty care. Basically, the clinic
would call the physician who provided the needed service — and would beg for help. It
was only natural, then, that each clinic fiercely protected its list. Certainly, none of the
clinics would share with any of the others. To do so would mean jeopardizing their vital
contacts in the medical community. After all, there weren’t that many physicians to go
around who would volunteer their services.
It was a situation in need of a remedy.
After all, it seemed that providing accessible, quality health care to the working poor
shouldn’t be an impossible dream. But to make that a reality would require a few
changes to the normal course of day-to-day business. One of the first things that Dr.
Uhlig understood was that all the diverse elements of the community needed to come
together: the doctors, the hospitals, the funders, the County Commissioners, the City
Council, the Mayor, the pharmacists, the clinics, the county health department, and, last
but not least, a government organization that everyone loved to hate: the state Medicaid
Agency — the office of Social and Rehabilitation Services (SRS).
The inspiration for this vision was found in a successful health care model being run out
of Asheville, North Carolina: Project Access. It was a program based upon creating a
closer relationship between primary care clinics and specialty care providers on behalf of
the uninsured. Asheville’s program began with a one-year health-planning grant and
continued with a three-year implementation grant — both from the Robert Wood Johnson
(RWJ) Foundation — as well as grants from other organizations. And it was winning
recognition and awards — such as the Innovations in American Government Award —
along the way.
This was clearly an idea worth exploring.
"We kept telling the community that we were looking for a better coordination of health
care delivery and this project just fell into our laps," remembers Carolyn Earnest, Nurse
Practioner, assistant to Dr. Uhlig and co-chair of the program’s Operations Council. "We
changed our focus from health care within the hospitals to looking at Project Access and
replicating it for our community. It was going to be only the first of several things that
we’d thought about and planned to do."
The reaction of the community, however, was not one of automatic trust. It was going to
take a great deal of effort to bring about a collaboration that would realize this vision.
To that end, Dr. Uhlig compiled a list of key local leaders in health care and education, as
well as city and county managers. Then, in September 1998, he arranged for eight of
them to be flown to Asheville to see what this Project Access was all about. The group
consisted of Wichita city manager Chris Cherches; University of Kansas School of
Medicine-Wichita (KUSM-W) dean, Joe Meek, M.D.; Max Bleck, chairman of the board
of Hunter Health Clinic; Ed Dismuke, M.D., chair of the Department of Preventive
Medicine, KUSM-W; David Grainger; M.D., board member of the Central Plains
Regional Health Care Foundation; Suzette Schwartz, CEO of Hunter Health Clinic;
The Stone Soup Story
(Excerpt adapted from the book
“Stone Soup” by Marcia Brown.)
Three soldiers trudged down a road in a strange country.
Suddenly, ahead of them they saw the lights of a village.
“Maybe we’ll find a bite to eat there,” said the first.
The soldiers stopped first at the house of Paul and Françoise.
“Good evening to you,” they said. “Could you spare a bit of food
for three hungry soldiers?”
“We have had no food for ourselves for three days,” said Paul.
At Vincent and Marie’s the answer was the same. It had been a
poor harvest and the grain must be kept for seed.
So it went all through the village.
Then the first soldier called out, “Good people! We are three
hungry soldiers in a strange land. We have asked you for food,
and you have no food. Well then, we’ll have to make stone soup.”
The peasants stared.
“First we’ll need a large iron pot,” the soldiers said.
The peasants brought the largest pot they could find. A fire was
built on the village square and the pot was set to boil.
“And now, if you please, three round, smooth stones.”
The peasants’ eyes grew round as they watched the soldiers drop
the stones into the pot.
“Any soup needs salt and pepper,” said the soldiers, as they began
to stir.
Children ran to fetch salt and pepper.
“Stones like these generally make good soup. But oh, if there
were carrots, it would be much better.”
“Why, I think I have a carrot or two,” said Françoise, and off she
ran. She came back with her apron full of carrots.
“A good stone soup should have cabbage,” said the soldiers as
they sliced the carrots into the pot.
“I think I can find a cabbage somewhere,” said Marie, and she
hurried home. Back she came with three cabbages.
“If we only had a bit of beef and a few potatoes, this soup would
be good enough for a rich man’s table.”
The peasants thought that over. They ran to fetch them.
“Ah,” sighed the soldiers as they stirred in the beef and potatoes,
“if we only had a little barley and a cup of milk! This soup would
be fit for the king himself.
The peasants brought their barley from the lofts, they brought their
milk from the wells.
At last the soup was ready.
Never had the peasants tasted such soup.
In the morning the whole village gathered in the square to give
them a send-off.
“Many thanks for what you have taught us,” the peasants said to
the soldiers. “We shall never go hungry, now that we know how
to make soup from stones.” |
|
Dwight Allen, executive director of Medical
Society of Sedgwick County (MSSC); and
Michael Bates, M.D., president of MSCC.
Over the course of several trips, the group
learned all the details of the Asheville model.
When they returned, each conveyed to their
Wichita/Sedgwick County peers what they
discovered about the success of Asheville’s
Project Access.
Communities, of course, are very different.
Asheville, for instance, was half the size of
Wichita/Sedgwick County, whose population
stands at about 550,000. But
Wichita/Sedgwick County had several
elements in its favor with respect to adopting
the Asheville project and taking it to the next
level.
To begin with, it’s more diverse in terms of
industry. And the culture is one that prides
itself on its entrepreneurial spirit. There’s an
interest in being independent; in building new
innovative ideas. Which is why many
companies began as start-ups here. There’s
also a community spirit among health
providers that’s essential in developing a
coordinated approach to health care. “It’s not
a splintered group, and not a lot of flow of
people moving in and out,” affirmed Dr.
Meek. It therefore seemed like a natural that
the many ostensibly divergent interests here
could come together under a single banner.
STONE SOUP: GOOD FOR THE COMMUNITY
The whole idea behind Project Access is one
of collaboration — everybody brings
something tangible to the table to make it
work. As Wesley Medical Center’s CEO,
022603 5
David Nevill, offered, “Project Access is kind of like the children’s tale of Stone Soup.”
(See inset.) The result being that there’s a greater positive effect for everyone as a result
of each self-interested party giving just a little:
Doctors could provide services to the uninsured without the fear of being
overwhelmed by them.
Clinics could get specialty treatment for the indigent without having to go begging,
which saves them time and effort.
Hospitals could contain costs for this particular patient population because their care
is better coordinated.
The community gets the economic benefit of a healthier, more productive population.
When Dr. Uhlig first approached his fellow physicians through the Medical Society, he
presented the idea to its board of directors. The board was immediately responsive and,
in turn, presented the idea to the physician membership.
The physicians were naturally skeptical. But Dr. Uhlig was persistent and, by showing a
great enthusiasm for a well-defined vision, he was able to turn his peers around quickly.
“We thought we should have a unanimous decision of the board, which we obtained. It
wouldn’t make sense to go to the hospitals with support from only 50% of the board,”
relayed Dwight Allen. It was at this time, in 1999, that the Medical Society, with the
agreement of the board of directors, took over the Central Plains Regional Health Care
Foundation, making it part of the Medical Society. The foundation’s board changed in
the process, with physicians subsequently comprising more of its membership.
Next came the clinics, who were hesitant because they thought they were already doing
good work. They thought nobody else had been out there getting the job done. And they
felt that they already had a connection to the University of Kansas School of Medicine-
Wichita (KUSM-W) and to the Sedgwick County Health Department. It’s also important
to point out that, because each of the clinics were operating under a tremendous amount
of stress, there existed an atmosphere of mistrust between them.
The fact is, yes, the clinics were already doing a wonderful job. But their efforts were
going unseen by most of the community.
And so, on April 15th, 1999, before an audience of 75 key local leaders at a community
forum, Dr. Uhlig introduced Asheville’s Project Access. At the invitation of Dr. Uhlig,
Alan McKenzie, director of the Medical Society in Asheville, presented the Asheville
model to the audience, relaying the steps they took to bring the project to fruition as well
as their discovery of who’s participation was necessary to make it all work. With this
model as a guide, many of the community’s fears were allayed.
“If we would have gone to the community without Asheville as an example and say we
want to bring you guys all together, people would have said ‘who are you? We’re
already together’ and ‘we’ve already created some major connections,’ ” Carolyn Earnest
proffered. But she added that while it was true that the community was making some
connections, it wasn’t doing it efficiently. Dr. Uhlig, however, was “taking something
that was already successfully formed and transforming it” to the needs of Wichita and
Sedgwick County.
In Wichita/Sedgwick County the pieces were already there, each developed and mature.
But they needed real coordination. Walls needed to come down. And everyone’s
competitive natures needed to be checked. (One of the Operations Council’s ongoing
tasks is the constant struggle to balance all the myriad relationships.) According to Dr.
Michael Bates, then-MSSC president, “This is a simple solution in which everyone helps
a little and everyone wins — our community becomes healthier and, most of all, patients
who need help receive the care many of us take for granted.”
After the Asheville trip, there were a number of strategy meetings between Dr. Uhlig and
the county manager. They agreed that the best way to get the city and the county to
support this idea was to make a presentation to both governing bodies. So a meeting was
set for the 1st of June, 1999. A team of people, including Dr. Uhlig, would do the
presentation.
At that meeting, the City Council and the County Commission were introduced to Project
Access. Asheville’s Alan McKenzie and his county manager, Wanda Green, both
described what their roles were, how Project Access evolved, and the subsequent changes
they saw in the community. Ms. Green also shared with the audience that Asheville’s
uninsured “became a healthier part of the community.” Indeed, Project Access created a
stronger workforce which, in turn, increased the number of small businesses in the
community. Because of Project Access, they saw a turnaround in their community’s
economic base.
All the key players were there at the meeting. It was one of the first times one could see
the city and county managers, the hospital CEOs, the newspaper publisher — all together
in one room — along with the Medical Society and the United Way. The pharmacists
were also represented.
Because Dr. Uhlig laid the groundwork and prepared both governing bodies for what was
to come, the meeting went smoothly, with very few questions, taking up very little time.
Sedgwick County manager Bill Buchanan and city manager Chris Cherches clearly
illustrated how the funding could work. In the end, it took less than an hour to approve
$500,000 of support for the prescription medication portion of Project Access.
According to Dr. Joe Meek, “It fell on fertile ground and so it took off easily. From then
on it was a matter of hiring superb personnel to run it.”
“The whole project, the whole concept itself, was one of those that every City Council
and County Commission member could relate to. It was something they understood, it
was something they supported,” observed Chris Cherches. He added, “when the medical
community showed support — which sometimes isn’t that easy — when they showed
they were behind this, it just kind of fell into place.”
After this historic June 1st meeting, the Operations Council, under a newly appointed
interim director, Betsy Bloxham, met once a week in intense meetings. They now faced
an actual deadline. Dr. Uhlig had set the date on which Project Access would handle its
first patient: September 1, 1999. This was done to create a specific, foreseeable goal and
to assertively push the community towards a realization of that goal. Likewise, a
monthly newsletter was created to keep all the key players informed of breaking news. It
was also important to keep the media attuned to what the Council was doing because they
were a resource, not only for PR but to keep the Council informed as to what was going
on in the community.
Then on September 1, 1999, under newly-hired permanent program director Anne
Nelson, Project Access officially “opened its doors” starting with the smallest clinic —
Guadalupe Clinic — and, as part of a deliberate, measured pace, continued the process of
adding one clinic a month to avoid overwhelming any of the participants. Project Access
was off and running and heading in the right direction.
And everyone in Wichita is better off because of it.